500 1st Street SE,
DEPENDABLE SOLUTIONS THAT MEET LOCAL NEEDS
Our mission is to assist companies and people with protecting and maximizing assets, resources, and opportunities
Dependable solutions that meet local needs
The First MainStreet Insurance platform offers independent agencies the opportunity to join forces with a larger firm and to gain access to robust resources, and carrier markets to support longevity and business growth.
150+ Direct Markets
50+ Indirect Markets
200+ Wholesales Relationships
$126mil of Direct Written Premium
“The market in 2023 has been tough. I can’t express how appreciative I am for the additional carriers that have been available to us through our partnership with FMSI. Without these additional resources, we would have been dead in the water in this current market.”
- Michael Lauer, Lauer & Lauer Insurance
“From the very first interaction, the First MainStreet partnership was a great fit for us. Our beliefs and business goals match perfectly."
- Mark Warth, Warth Insurance Agency
“In our current environment of M&A, I needed a partner that would bring size, markets, a streamlined process and back room support."
- Tom Kellenberger, United Insurance Counselors
Executive Vice President
Director Strategic Expansion
Chief Legal Officer & Secretary
Director of Finance